Extra Creamy. Peanut Butter Ice Cream with a Fudge Swirl. 2007 ChefsBest, Best Taste Award. The ChefsBest Award for Best Taste is awarded to the brand rated highest overall among leading brands by independent professional chefs. 1/2 the Fat. 140 calories per serving. 25% Less calories than regular ice cream. Our unique Double Churned process gently churns the ice cream twice to create a taste as rich and creamy as regular ice cream with half the fat! Weight Watcher's Points = 3. Breyers Peanut Butter Light Ice Cream - 140 calories, 5g Fat per serving. Regular Ice Cream - 190 Calories, 11g Fat per serving.